What if one of the most influential ideas in modern Christianity… didn’t actually come from Jesus?
In this episode of The Deconstructionists Podcast, we explore the history and impact of dualism — the ancient belief that spirit is good while matter, bodies, and the physical world are somehow lesser, corrupt, or evil.
From Plato and Greek philosophy to Gnosticism and modern evangelical culture, we trace how dualistic thinking quietly shaped theology, sexuality, purity culture, views of the body, the afterlife, politics, and even the way many Christians understand salvation itself.
We ask questions like:
- Why have so many Christians viewed the body with suspicion?
- Did the Bible actually teach a sharp divide between “spiritual” and “physical”?
- How did Greek philosophy influence early Christianity?
- Why do some forms of Christianity focus so heavily on “escaping the world”?
- What happens when faith becomes disconnected from embodiment, justice, and humanity?
- And what might a more holistic, integrated spirituality look like?
Along the way, we discuss:
- Plato and the influence of Greek metaphysics
- Gnosticism and the material/spiritual divide
- The Hebrew understanding of embodied humanity
- Paul’s writings and common misunderstandings about “flesh”
- Heaven, resurrection, and the renewal of creation
- Purity culture and body shame
- The lasting influence of dualism on modern evangelicalism
- Deconstruction, embodiment, and recovering wholeness
This conversation explores how ideas developed historically — and how those ideas still shape people’s lives today, often in ways they don’t even realize.
Whether you come from an evangelical background, are in the middle of deconstruction, or are simply interested in theology, philosophy, and history, this episode offers a deeper look at one of the hidden frameworks underneath modern Christianity.
Topics Covered
- Dualism in Christianity
- Plato and Greek philosophy
- Gnosticism
- Embodiment and spirituality
- Resurrection theology
- Purity culture
- Biblical anthropology
- Evangelical theology
- Deconstruction and reconstruction
- Mind/body divide
- Spiritual formation
Support The Deconstructionists
If you enjoy the show and want to support independent conversations like this, consider joining us on Patreon for:
- Ad-free episodes
- Bonus content
- Extended interviews
- Educational deep dives
- Community discussions
Link: https://www.patreon.com/cw/TheDeconstructionistsPodcast
You can also grab merch and find all of our links here:
www.thedeconstructionists.org
Follow The Deconstructionists
- YouTube
If this episode resonated with you, leaving a review and sharing the episode helps more than you know.
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
00:00 --> 00:02 [SPEAKER_00]: Welcome to the deconstructionist podcast.
00:02 --> 00:03 [SPEAKER_00]: I'm your host John Williamson.
00:04 --> 00:09 [SPEAKER_00]: And before we jump into today's episode, I just want to take a quick moment to say thank you.
00:10 --> 00:20 [SPEAKER_00]: If you've been listening to the deconstruction for a while now, all the way back to the beginning, a decade ago this year, or just recently found the show, I'm really grateful that you're here.
00:21 --> 00:24 [SPEAKER_00]: This podcast has always been about creating space for honest questions.
00:25 --> 00:31 [SPEAKER_00]: thoughtful conversations and learning from people who've dedicated their lives to studying these very topics.
00:32 --> 00:38 [SPEAKER_00]: If you'd like to support the show, there are a few really helpful ways to do that, and we've made it as easy as possible.
00:38 --> 00:42 [SPEAKER_00]: So first of all, we've just launched a brand new Patreon,
00:43 --> 00:51 [SPEAKER_00]: with a lot of really great content, including ad free episodes, extended interviews and exclusive material you won't hear or see anywhere else.
00:52 --> 00:58 [SPEAKER_00]: If you want to go deeper with the show, that's probably the best place to start and there's some very affordable options on there.
00:58 --> 01:04 [SPEAKER_00]: We've also got a merch store with some brand new designs along with some of your favorite classics.
01:05 --> 01:09 [SPEAKER_00]: Every purchase there helps support the work we're doing and keeps the show independent
01:12 --> 01:18 [SPEAKER_00]: And if you're looking for a completely free way to support the podcast, one of the most helpful things you can do is leave a rating or review wherever you listen.
01:19 --> 01:22 [SPEAKER_00]: It really does make a difference in helping people find the show.
01:23 --> 01:27 [SPEAKER_00]: And you can find all of the links to all of that stuff in the show notes.
01:28 --> 01:30 [SPEAKER_00]: Alright, so let's jump in.
01:30 --> 01:34 [SPEAKER_00]: This is a topic that I have wanted to cover for quite some time.
01:34 --> 01:39 [SPEAKER_00]: And it is the concept of dualism, which, you know, if you've been listening for a while, we've brought up before.
01:39 --> 01:44 [SPEAKER_00]: We've talked about before with other guests, famously with Father Richard Rourke.
01:45 --> 01:54 [SPEAKER_00]: but it's something I've definitely wanted to cover and so I want to jump into it and so we'll cover the history not like we normally do and we'll also talk about ways in which it can be harmful.
01:54 --> 02:02 [SPEAKER_00]: So let's talk about what if one of the most influential ideas in modern Christianity isn't actually Christian at all?
02:03 --> 02:11 [SPEAKER_00]: What if the way many of us were taught to see the world spirit versus body, sacred versus secular, saved versus lost?
02:11 --> 02:11 [SPEAKER_00]: I know that's a big one.
02:13 --> 02:18 [SPEAKER_00]: was never really the framework Jesus, or the earliest followers of his movement were working from.
02:19 --> 02:20 [SPEAKER_00]: And what if that split?
02:20 --> 02:26 [SPEAKER_00]: That deep divide between the spiritual and the physical has shaped far more than just theology.
02:27 --> 02:48 [SPEAKER_00]: What of it has shaped how we see our bodies, how we understand suffering, how we think about sex, how we relate to people outside our tribe, how churches handle abuse, how leaders justify harm, how entire religious systems learn to protect what they call the mission while overlooking the damage done to actual human beings.
02:49 --> 03:00 [SPEAKER_00]: Because once you divide reality into higher and lower, sacred and profane, eternal and disposable, it gets a lot easier to decide what matters most.
03:01 --> 03:03 [SPEAKER_00]: And a lot easier to excuse what doesn't.
03:05 --> 03:23 [SPEAKER_00]: In this episode, I want to explore the idea of dualism, what it is, where it came from, how it found its way into Christianity and why so many respected scholars argue that it has distorted both Christian theology and Christian practice in ways that have done real harm.
03:24 --> 03:35 [SPEAKER_00]: So, before we jump in, I want to begin with something I think is important to say clearly, and I've said this before and I will say it again, I am not a biblical scholar.
03:35 --> 03:39 [SPEAKER_00]: I am not a Christian historian, and I'm not pretending to be one.
03:40 --> 03:57 [SPEAKER_00]: What I am is someone who has had the enormous privilege over many years of doing this podcast to sit with biblical scholars, theologians, historians, archaeologists, and other experts who have devoted their lives to studying these questions.
03:57 --> 03:58 [SPEAKER_00]: So...
03:59 --> 04:05 [SPEAKER_00]: Whenever we cover a topic like this, I always want to be clear that I'm not speaking as an authority over the field.
04:06 --> 04:19 [SPEAKER_00]: I'm speaking as a student of it, so I'm trying to synthesize what these scholars have taught, and trying to make that scholarship accessible to people like me who didn't get a PhD, but still deeply care about what is true.
04:20 --> 04:20 [SPEAKER_00]: So as always,
04:21 --> 04:30 [SPEAKER_00]: I want to encourage you not to take my word for any of this, but to follow the scholarship, read the books, and explore the arguments for yourself.
04:31 --> 04:39 [SPEAKER_00]: For this episode, I'm drawing from the work of a number of respected scholars in biblical studies, theology, philosophy, and church history.
04:40 --> 04:42 [SPEAKER_00]: A few people to name people like Joel B.
04:42 --> 05:02 [SPEAKER_00]: Green and T. Wright, Nancy Murphy, Elaine Pagels, James K. A Smith, Dallas Willard, Lynn Rudder Baker and others who have written extensively on the nature of the human person, the body, the soul, resurrection, narcissism, and the long influence of dualistic thinking on Christian theology.
05:03 --> 05:05 [SPEAKER_00]: And as always, we'll include a list of sources
05:10 --> 05:18 [SPEAKER_00]: because this is one of those topics that at first glance can feel abstract, philosophical, maybe even a little removed from real life.
05:19 --> 05:21 [SPEAKER_00]: But I don't think it is.
05:21 --> 05:29 [SPEAKER_00]: In fact, I think dualistic thinking may be one of the hidden engines beneath a lot of what so many of us have spent years trying to entangle.
05:30 --> 05:41 [SPEAKER_00]: from body shame and purity culture to spiritual bypassing, to institutional protection, to the kinds of systems I spent so much time examining and spoiled fruit faith and power.
05:42 --> 05:59 [SPEAKER_00]: Because once a religious system starts training people to think that the spiritual always matters more than the physical, that the higher things matter more than the human ones, that doctrine, image, mission, and authority matter more than the embodied reality.
05:59 --> 06:03 [SPEAKER_00]: Well, by that point, the damage is already underway.
06:04 --> 06:05 [SPEAKER_00]: So let's start at the beginning.
06:06 --> 06:09 [SPEAKER_00]: What do we actually mean when we use the word dualism?
06:10 --> 06:13 [SPEAKER_00]: So what exactly do we mean when we talk about dualism?
06:15 --> 06:22 [SPEAKER_00]: At its most basic level, dualism is the idea that reality is divided into two fundamentally different kinds of things.
06:22 --> 06:31 [SPEAKER_00]: Two categories, two layers, two kinds of existence that are often seen as separate, and sometimes even intention with each other.
06:33 --> 06:42 [SPEAKER_00]: In philosophical terms, this often shows up as a distinction between the mind and the body, or the soul and the body, the immaterial and the material.
06:43 --> 06:50 [SPEAKER_00]: But in religious contexts and especially within Christianity, it tends to show up in a slightly different way.
06:50 --> 06:51 [SPEAKER_00]: Spirit vs.
06:51 --> 06:58 [SPEAKER_00]: Body, Heaven vs. Earth, Sacred vs. Secular, Eternal vs.
06:58 --> 06:59 [SPEAKER_00]: Temporary.
07:00 --> 07:07 [SPEAKER_00]: And often, whether it's said explicitly or just assumed, one side of that divide is seen as more important than the other.
07:08 --> 07:09 [SPEAKER_00]: The spiritual is higher.
07:10 --> 07:11 [SPEAKER_00]: The physical is lower.
07:12 --> 07:14 [SPEAKER_00]: The eternal matters more than the present.
07:14 --> 07:16 [SPEAKER_00]: The soul matters more than the body.
07:18 --> 07:21 [SPEAKER_00]: And again, this isn't always something that's taught outright.
07:22 --> 07:25 [SPEAKER_00]: Most of us didn't grow up hearing a sermon titled, why the body doesn't matter.
07:30 --> 07:34 [SPEAKER_00]: In the way faith was framed as something primarily about what happens after we die.
07:35 --> 07:40 [SPEAKER_00]: In the way certain parts of life were labeled spiritual, while everything else was just life.
07:41 --> 07:49 [SPEAKER_00]: In the way questions about bodies, sexuality, or mental health were often treated as secondary, or even suspect.
07:50 --> 07:54 [SPEAKER_00]: Compared to questions about belief, salvation, or doctrine.
07:55 --> 08:02 [SPEAKER_00]: And over time, that framework becomes a lens, a way of seeing the world that feels natural even obvious.
08:03 --> 08:15 [SPEAKER_00]: But one of the things many scholars have pointed out is that we have to be careful here, because not every distinction is the same as a division, and not every distinction leads to hierarchy.
08:16 --> 08:21 [SPEAKER_00]: There's a difference between saying that humans are complex and saying that humans are split.
08:22 --> 08:33 [SPEAKER_00]: There's a difference between acknowledging that there are spiritual dimensions to life and assuming that those dimensions exist in opposition to or at the expense of the physical world.
08:34 --> 08:35 [SPEAKER_00]: And that distinction matters.
08:36 --> 08:43 [SPEAKER_00]: Because once a division becomes a hierarchy, once one side is consistently elevated above the other,
08:44 --> 08:47 [SPEAKER_00]: It starts to shape not just theology, but values.
08:48 --> 08:56 [SPEAKER_00]: What we prioritize, what we neglect, what we protect, and sometimes what we're willing to overlook.
08:58 --> 09:01 [SPEAKER_00]: So before we go any further, it's important to say this clearly.
09:02 --> 09:09 [SPEAKER_00]: Not all forms of dualism are the same, and not all distinctions within Christianity are inherently harmful.
09:10 --> 09:15 [SPEAKER_00]: The question isn't whether Christianity recognizes different aspects of human existence.
09:16 --> 09:22 [SPEAKER_00]: The question is whether those aspects were ever meant to be separated in the way many of us have come to assume.
09:23 --> 09:26 [SPEAKER_00]: And to answer that question, we have to go back.
09:27 --> 09:29 [SPEAKER_00]: Not just to the early church, but even further.
09:30 --> 09:34 [SPEAKER_00]: Because the roots of this way of thinking didn't begin with Christianity at all.
09:37 --> 09:37 [SPEAKER_00]: All right.
09:37 --> 09:39 [SPEAKER_00]: This is for all my fellow history nerds out there.
09:39 --> 09:46 [SPEAKER_00]: So if dualism wasn't originally part of early Christian thinking in the way many assume, then where did it come from?
09:47 --> 09:54 [SPEAKER_00]: Well, to answer that, we have to step outside of Christianity for a moment and look at the broader philosophical world that early Christians were living in.
09:55 --> 09:59 [SPEAKER_00]: Because the earliest followers of Jesus were not operating in a vacuum.
10:00 --> 10:02 [SPEAKER_00]: They were part of a world shaped by Greek philosophy.
10:03 --> 10:09 [SPEAKER_00]: A world where certain ideas about the nature of reality, the body and the soul were already deeply embedded.
10:10 --> 10:15 [SPEAKER_00]: And one of the most influential voices in that world was the Greek philosopher Plato.
10:16 --> 10:24 [SPEAKER_00]: Now, without going too far down the philosophical rabbit hole because I do love some Plato, Plato's basic framework looked something like this.
10:24 --> 10:33 [SPEAKER_00]: The material world, the physical world we experience through our senses, was seen as temporary, changing and ultimately less real.
10:34 --> 10:39 [SPEAKER_00]: But beyond that world, there was a higher reality, a world of eternal, unchanging forms.
10:40 --> 10:46 [SPEAKER_00]: and the human soul and Plato's view belong more to that higher realm than to the physical body.
10:47 --> 10:53 [SPEAKER_00]: So the body became something like a container, or even in some interpretations a kind of prison.
10:54 --> 10:57 [SPEAKER_00]: And the goal of life was, in some sense, to transcend it.
10:58 --> 11:03 [SPEAKER_00]: Now you can probably already hear how ideas like that could begin to overlap a certain
11:08 --> 11:19 [SPEAKER_00]: And over time, as Christianity spread into the Greco-Roman world, in inevitably began interacting with, and in some cases absorbing those philosophical categories.
11:20 --> 11:25 [SPEAKER_00]: But here's where things get really important, because not all of those ideas were embraced.
11:26 --> 11:34 [SPEAKER_00]: In fact, some of the earliest Christian thinkers pushed back hard against forms of dualism that they believed went too far.
11:35 --> 11:40 [SPEAKER_00]: And this is where movements like narcissism and later manicaiism come into the picture.
11:40 --> 11:46 [SPEAKER_00]: And I'm sorry if I mispronounced that last word again, not a biblical scholar, but you get the idea.
11:47 --> 11:53 [SPEAKER_00]: Narcissism wasn't a single unified movement, but a collection of beliefs that began to emerge in the first few centuries after Jesus.
11:54 --> 12:04 [SPEAKER_00]: And at the heart of many Nostick systems was a very strong form of dualism, and in these systems the material world wasn't just less important.
12:04 --> 12:08 [SPEAKER_00]: It was often seen as fundamentally flawed, or even evil.
12:09 --> 12:18 [SPEAKER_00]: Some Nostick texts describe the physical world as a creation of a lesser or misguided divine being, something distinct from the true higher God.
12:19 --> 12:25 [SPEAKER_00]: which meant that salvation wasn't about the redemption of creation, it was about escape from it.
12:26 --> 12:29 [SPEAKER_00]: Escape from the body, escape from the material world.
12:29 --> 12:45 [SPEAKER_00]: One example comes from texts like the Gospel of Thomas, where salvation is framed less as transformation of the world and more as awakening to hidden knowledge, an internal realization that frees you from the illusions of the physical realm.
12:46 --> 12:53 [SPEAKER_00]: In other Nostig writings, the body is described almost like a trap, something to be transcended rather than restored.
12:54 --> 13:02 [SPEAKER_00]: And the way out isn't resurrection, it's knowledge, secret knowledge, hidden insight, a kind of awakening to your true spiritual nature.
13:03 --> 13:09 [SPEAKER_00]: Scholars like Elaine Pagels have done extensive work on covering these texts and showing
13:15 --> 13:20 [SPEAKER_00]: A few centuries later, another movement emerged that took dualism even further.
13:21 --> 13:21 [SPEAKER_00]: Manakaiism.
13:22 --> 13:29 [SPEAKER_00]: Founded in the third century by a figure named Moni, Manakaiism taught a kind of cosmic dualism.
13:29 --> 13:38 [SPEAKER_00]: A universe fundamentally divided between two opposing forces, light and darkness, good and evil, spirit, and matter.
13:39 --> 13:50 [SPEAKER_00]: But unlike Christianity, where evil is not equal to God, Manakaiism treated these forces as more or less co-eternal, locked in an ongoing cosmic struggle.
13:51 --> 13:57 [SPEAKER_00]: In this system, the material world was seen as a mixture of light trapped in darkness.
13:58 --> 14:03 [SPEAKER_00]: Human beings, then, were understood as spiritual light imprisoned within physical bodies.
14:04 --> 14:13 [SPEAKER_00]: In salvation, once again, it wasn't about restoring the world, it was about escaping it, freeing the light from the prison of matter.
14:16 --> 14:18 [SPEAKER_00]: What's important for our purposes is this.
14:19 --> 14:28 [SPEAKER_00]: Many early Christian leaders did not embrace these ideas, they rejected them, because they saw them as incompatible with core elements of the Christian story.
14:29 --> 14:41 [SPEAKER_00]: If creation is good, if God becomes embodied in Jesus, if resurrection is central to the story, then the material world can't simply be dismissed as corrupt or irrelevant.
14:42 --> 14:44 [SPEAKER_00]: The body can't just be a shell to escape.
14:45 --> 14:49 [SPEAKER_00]: And salvation can't just mean leaving the physical world behind.
14:50 --> 15:01 [SPEAKER_00]: So, in many ways, what we now think of as, quote, Orthodox Christianity, was formed in part by pushing back against these more extreme forms of dualism.
15:01 --> 15:09 [SPEAKER_00]: And yet, even as these more radical forms were rejected, some of the underlying assumptions didn't fully disappear.
15:10 --> 15:15 [SPEAKER_00]: Because ideas have a way of sticking around, especially when they're already embedded in the culture.
15:16 --> 15:22 [SPEAKER_00]: And over time, more subtle forms of dualistic thinking began to find their way into Christian theology.
15:23 --> 15:31 [SPEAKER_00]: Not always in explicit, system-attized ways, but in tone, and emphasis, in the way certain questions were framed.
15:32 --> 15:36 [SPEAKER_00]: The body wasn't necessarily evil, but it became secondary.
15:37 --> 15:41 [SPEAKER_00]: The physical world wasn't rejected outright, but it became something to move beyond.
15:42 --> 15:47 [SPEAKER_00]: and slowly, almost imperceptibly, a shift began to take place.
15:49 --> 15:51 [SPEAKER_00]: One that would shape centuries of theology.
15:51 --> 15:56 [SPEAKER_00]: And eventually, the kind of Christianity that many of us inherited.
15:58 --> 16:10 [SPEAKER_00]: So the question becomes, when we turn to the Bible itself, when we step back from philosophy from later theology, from inherited assumptions, do we actually find this kind of split?
16:11 --> 16:14 [SPEAKER_00]: or do we find something else entirely?
16:17 --> 16:21 [SPEAKER_00]: So with all of that in mind, we come to a really important question.
16:22 --> 16:33 [SPEAKER_00]: When we look at the Bible itself, when we try to set aside later philosophy, later theology, and the assumptions many of us inherited, do we actually find this kind of dualism?
16:34 --> 16:39 [SPEAKER_00]: Do we find a clear division between body and soul, where one is higher in the other is lower?
16:40 --> 16:42 [SPEAKER_00]: Or, do we find something else?
16:43 --> 16:57 [SPEAKER_00]: One of the things many biblical scholars point out is that the earliest parts of the Bible, the Hebrew Scriptures, what Christians call the Old Testament, doesn't describe human beings and dualistic terms, at least, not in the way many of us were taught.
16:59 --> 17:08 [SPEAKER_00]: Instead of dividing the person into separate parts, body here, so there, the Hebrew worldview tends to describe human beings more holistically.
17:09 --> 17:14 [SPEAKER_00]: As a unified whole, one of the key words here is the Hebrew word Nefesh.
17:15 --> 17:19 [SPEAKER_00]: Now, Nefesh is often translated into English as Soul.
17:20 --> 17:32 [SPEAKER_00]: But that translation can be misleading, because when most of us hear the word Soul, we think of something like a ghost inside the body, something separate, something that can exist independently.
17:33 --> 17:37 [SPEAKER_00]: But that's not really how Nefesh functions in the Hebrew Bible.
17:39 --> 17:42 [SPEAKER_00]: Nefesh doesn't mean a soul that you have.
17:43 --> 17:46 [SPEAKER_00]: It's closer to a living being that you are.
17:47 --> 17:55 [SPEAKER_00]: It refers to the whole person, their life, their breath, their physical existence, their embodied self.
17:56 --> 18:02 [SPEAKER_00]: So when the text talks about a Nefesh, it's not talking about a detachable spiritual component.
18:03 --> 18:05 [SPEAKER_00]: It's talking about a living, breathing, human being.
18:07 --> 18:10 [SPEAKER_00]: This also shows up in how the Hebrew scriptures talk about life and death.
18:11 --> 18:21 [SPEAKER_00]: Death isn't described as the separation of the soul from the body, and the way later Christian language sometimes suggests, it's the end of the whole person's life.
18:22 --> 18:28 [SPEAKER_00]: And whatever hope exists, whether it's vague or developing over time, it's not centered
18:34 --> 18:55 [SPEAKER_00]: Now, when we move into the new testament, things do get more complex, because now we're in a Greek-speaking world, and the language itself, Greek, does have more built-in philosophical categories that can sound dualistic, words like psyche and soma often translated as soul and body start to appear.
18:56 --> 18:58 [SPEAKER_00]: but here's where scholars urge caution.
18:59 --> 19:04 [SPEAKER_00]: Just because the language can sound dualistic, doesn't mean the underlying worldview actually is.
19:05 --> 19:07 [SPEAKER_00]: Scholars like Joel B.
19:07 --> 19:15 [SPEAKER_00]: Green, argue that the New Testament writers are still largely operating within a holistic Jewish framework, even as they're using Greek words.
19:16 --> 19:27 [SPEAKER_00]: So in other words, the vocabulary may shift, but the deeper assumptions about what it means to be human, don't necessarily follow Greek dualism as closely as we might think.
19:30 --> 19:36 [SPEAKER_00]: And this becomes especially clear when we look at one of the central ideas of Christianity, Resurrection.
19:37 --> 19:46 [SPEAKER_00]: As NT Wright has argued extensively, the early Christian hope wasn't about souls leaving bodies and going to heaven forever or what we call escape theology.
19:47 --> 19:55 [SPEAKER_00]: It was about resurrection, about new and body life, about God restoring and renewing creation, not abandoning it.
19:55 --> 19:57 [SPEAKER_00]: And that's a very different picture.
19:58 --> 20:02 [SPEAKER_00]: Because if the ultimate goal is resurrection, then the body isn't disposable.
20:03 --> 20:05 [SPEAKER_00]: The physical world isn't irrelevant.
20:06 --> 20:10 [SPEAKER_00]: and salvation isn't about escape, it's about restoration.
20:12 --> 20:21 [SPEAKER_00]: So if the biblical story itself leans more toward a unified embodied understanding of human life, then it raises an important question.
20:22 --> 20:27 [SPEAKER_00]: How did so many of us end up with a version of Christianity that feels so divided?
20:28 --> 20:36 [SPEAKER_00]: where the soul feels primary, where the body feels secondary, where the ultimate goal often sounds like leaving this world behind.
20:37 --> 20:40 [SPEAKER_00]: That's not a question with a simple, single answer either.
20:41 --> 20:49 [SPEAKER_00]: But many scholars suggest that it has less to do with the Bible itself, and more to do with what happened as Christianity moved through different cultures,
20:56 --> 21:05 [SPEAKER_00]: And once that split takes hold, to once the spiritual and the physical start to be separated and then ranked, it doesn't just stay in the realm of ideas.
21:06 --> 21:14 [SPEAKER_00]: It starts to shape how people live, how they see themselves, how they see others, and how entire systems begin to function.
21:16 --> 21:23 [SPEAKER_00]: So if dualism isn't as clearly rooted in the biblical text as many of us were taught, and if it developed gradually through philosophical
21:26 --> 21:29 [SPEAKER_00]: Then, the next question becomes then why does it matter?
21:30 --> 21:35 [SPEAKER_00]: Why spend this much time unpacking something that on the surface can feel abstract or theoretical?
21:36 --> 21:40 [SPEAKER_00]: Because dualism isn't just an idea, it's a framework.
21:41 --> 21:45 [SPEAKER_00]: A way of organizing reality that shapes how people interpret everything else.
21:46 --> 21:51 [SPEAKER_00]: What matters, what doesn't, what gets prioritized, and what gets minimized.
21:52 --> 22:00 [SPEAKER_00]: And once that framework is in place, especially within a religious system, it starts to produce real-world consequences.
22:02 --> 22:07 [SPEAKER_00]: One of the most widely discussed consequences is the gradual devaluing of the body.
22:08 --> 22:12 [SPEAKER_00]: Not always explicitly, but subtly, systematically.
22:13 --> 22:19 [SPEAKER_00]: If the soul is what ultimately matters, if the spiritual life is what's most important,
22:20 --> 22:22 [SPEAKER_00]: then the body can begin to feel secondary.
22:23 --> 22:27 [SPEAKER_00]: Temporary, less significant, even suspect.
22:28 --> 22:31 [SPEAKER_00]: And historically, this has shown up in a number of ways.
22:32 --> 22:39 [SPEAKER_00]: In the way sexuality is often treated, not just as something to be guided, but as something to be feared or controlled.
22:39 --> 22:44 [SPEAKER_00]: In the way physical experience, pleasure, pain, and bodyment
22:48 --> 22:54 [SPEAKER_00]: And in some cases, and the way people are encouraged to distrust their own bodies altogether.
22:56 --> 22:59 [SPEAKER_00]: Dualism also reshapes out of salvation itself is understood.
23:00 --> 23:17 [SPEAKER_00]: Instead of being about the restoration of the whole person, and ultimately, the renewal of creation, it can become framed as escape, leaving the body behind, leaving the world behind, moving from the lower realm to the higher one.
23:18 --> 23:24 [SPEAKER_00]: As anti-right has pointed out, this shift dramatically changes the story Christianity tells about the future.
23:25 --> 23:35 [SPEAKER_00]: Because if the end goal is disembodied existence, then the physical world becomes at best, temporary, and at worst irrelevant.
23:37 --> 23:42 [SPEAKER_00]: Another effective dualistic thinking is that it tends to simplify moral categories.
23:43 --> 23:57 [SPEAKER_00]: Once reality is divided into two opposing sides, it becomes much easier to divide people the same way, saved or unsaved, in or out, pure or impure, truth or deception.
23:58 --> 24:03 [SPEAKER_00]: And while those categories can feel clear, they often come at the cost of nuance.
24:04 --> 24:08 [SPEAKER_00]: Complexity gets flattened, ambiguity disappears.
24:09 --> 24:14 [SPEAKER_00]: and people are reduced to categories rather than understood as whole human beings.
24:17 --> 24:20 [SPEAKER_00]: This is where things begin to intersect directly with systems.
24:22 --> 24:33 [SPEAKER_00]: Because once a framework is in place where the spiritual is consistently elevated about the physical, it becomes possible, sometimes even easy to justify harm.
24:39 --> 24:55 [SPEAKER_00]: If the mission is spiritual, if the stakes are eternal, if what's happening in the spirit matters more than what's happening in someone's lived embodied experience, then the real world harm can start to feel secondary.
24:57 --> 25:00 [SPEAKER_00]: And this is something that we explored in spoiled fruit faith and power.
25:01 --> 25:08 [SPEAKER_00]: In case, after case, we saw situations where institutional priorities were framed in spiritual terms.
25:09 --> 25:11 [SPEAKER_00]: Leadership authority was framed in spiritual terms.
25:12 --> 25:15 [SPEAKER_00]: The success of the church was framed in spiritual terms.
25:17 --> 25:20 [SPEAKER_00]: And in that environment, when harm occurred,
25:21 --> 25:24 [SPEAKER_00]: whether it was abuse, manipulation, or systemic failure.
25:25 --> 25:35 [SPEAKER_00]: It often wasn't addressed with the same urgency, because something else was seen as more important, something higher, something spiritual.
25:37 --> 25:40 [SPEAKER_00]: And that's one of the most concerning aspects of dualistic thinking.
25:41 --> 25:44 [SPEAKER_00]: It doesn't just divide reality, it ranks it.
25:47 --> 25:48 [SPEAKER_00]: And once you start ranking reality,
25:49 --> 25:54 [SPEAKER_00]: You create a framework where certain kinds of harm can be minimized in the name of something greater.
25:57 --> 26:08 [SPEAKER_00]: There's also a more internal effect, because when people are taught explicitly or implicitly, that their spiritual self is what really matters.
26:09 --> 26:16 [SPEAKER_00]: It can create a disconnect from other parts of their experience, from their body, from their emotions, from their mental health.
26:18 --> 26:19 [SPEAKER_00]: philosophers like James K.A.
26:20 --> 26:35 [SPEAKER_00]: Smith have pointed out that many modern expressions of Christianity unintentionally reduce people to thinking things, almost like brains on a stick, where belief becomes central and the rest of human experience becomes secondary.
26:36 --> 26:40 [SPEAKER_00]: And over time, that kind of fragmentation can take a toll.
26:47 --> 26:54 [SPEAKER_00]: because Paul does use language that sounds dualistic at times, especially when he talks about things like flesh and spirit.
26:55 --> 26:57 [SPEAKER_00]: But here again, scholars urge caution.
26:58 --> 27:03 [SPEAKER_00]: In many cases, Paul isn't contrasting the physical body with an immaterial soul.
27:04 --> 27:06 [SPEAKER_00]: He's contrasting two ways of living.
27:08 --> 27:15 [SPEAKER_00]: A life-oriented, around self-interest, injustice, and brokenness, versus a life-oriented, around God's spirit.
27:16 --> 27:22 [SPEAKER_00]: In other words, flesh isn't just the body, and spirit isn't just something non-physical.
27:23 --> 27:27 [SPEAKER_00]: There are categories of existence, ways of being in the world.
27:29 --> 27:37 [SPEAKER_00]: And when read with his Jewish context, Paul's vision is still ultimately embodied, pointing toward resurrection and not escape.
27:44 --> 27:47 [SPEAKER_00]: The dualism doesn't just shape abstract theology.
27:48 --> 27:57 [SPEAKER_00]: It shapes how people understand themselves, how they relate to their bodies, how they treat others, and how institutions make decisions.
27:58 --> 28:03 [SPEAKER_00]: It shapes what gets prioritized, and sometimes what gets ignored.
28:04 --> 28:08 [SPEAKER_00]: So if that's the problem, the next question is,
28:09 --> 28:10 [SPEAKER_00]: Is there another way to see this?
28:11 --> 28:17 [SPEAKER_00]: Is there a way of understanding Christianity and ourselves that doesn't rely on splitting reality in two?
28:20 --> 28:31 [SPEAKER_00]: So if dualism has shaped so much of how Christianity has been understood, and in some cases distorted, the natural question is, is there another way to see this?
28:32 --> 28:40 [SPEAKER_00]: Is there a way of understanding Christianity and ourselves that doesn't rely on splitting reality into competing parts?
28:42 --> 28:57 [SPEAKER_00]: One of the things many contemporary Theologians and Biblical scholars have been doing over the last several decades is revisiting the Biblical text, trying to peel back layers of philosophical influence and recover a more integrated vision of the human person.
28:59 --> 29:03 [SPEAKER_00]: And what they often point to is something much less divided, much more whole.
29:05 --> 29:12 [SPEAKER_00]: Theologians like Nancy Murphy argue that human beings are not best understood as a combination of separate parts.
29:12 --> 29:17 [SPEAKER_00]: Body here, soul there, but as integrated embodied selves.
29:18 --> 29:24 [SPEAKER_00]: Not a soul trapped in a body, but a person who is their body, their mind, their relationships,
29:29 --> 29:34 [SPEAKER_00]: In this view, the spiritual life isn't something that happens apart from the physical world.
29:35 --> 29:36 [SPEAKER_00]: It happens through it.
29:38 --> 29:41 [SPEAKER_00]: This is where thinkers like Dallas Willard and James K.A.
29:41 --> 29:43 [SPEAKER_00]: Smith have been especially helpful.
29:44 --> 29:51 [SPEAKER_00]: They push back against the idea that faith is primarily about belief, about what you think or affirm internally.
29:53 --> 30:04 [SPEAKER_00]: Instead, they emphasize that human beings are shaped by practices, by habits, by embodied life, by what we do with our bodies as much as what we believe in our minds.
30:06 --> 30:13 [SPEAKER_00]: And that reframe spirituality entirely, because it means that the physical world isn't a distraction from the spiritual life.
30:14 --> 30:16 [SPEAKER_00]: It's the place where it actually happens.
30:23 --> 30:29 [SPEAKER_00]: not escape, but redemption, not leaving the world behind, but the renewal of it.
30:30 --> 30:44 [SPEAKER_00]: As NT Wright emphasizes the Christian story is ultimately about resurrection, about God restoring what has been broken, which means the physical world matters, bodies matter, justice matters,
30:50 --> 31:00 [SPEAKER_00]: And this is where this conversation moves beyond theology and into systems, because dualistic thinking doesn't just divide spirit and body.
31:00 --> 31:17 [SPEAKER_00]: It also tends to divide people into categories, into camps, into those who are in and those who are out, those who are right, those who are wrong, those who belong and those who don't.
31:18 --> 31:23 [SPEAKER_00]: and when that way of thinking becomes embedded in a religious system, it can scale.
31:24 --> 31:30 [SPEAKER_00]: It can move from personal belief to institutional structure to political ideology.
31:32 --> 31:36 [SPEAKER_00]: What example of this is what we see in movements like Christian nationalism?
31:37 --> 31:40 [SPEAKER_00]: Identity, faith and power become intertwined.
31:41 --> 31:45 [SPEAKER_00]: and where the world is often framed in stark binary terms.
31:46 --> 31:51 [SPEAKER_00]: Us and them, good and evil, righteous and corrupt.
31:53 --> 31:57 [SPEAKER_00]: And in that kind of framework, complexity becomes a threat.
31:58 --> 32:03 [SPEAKER_00]: New wants becomes dangerous, because the system depends on maintaining clear boundaries,
32:10 --> 32:25 [SPEAKER_00]: But if the biblical story is less about division, and more about restoration, if it's less about separating the spiritual from the physical, and more about integrating them, then it opens the door to a very different kind of framework.
32:27 --> 32:33 [SPEAKER_00]: One where people aren't reduced to categories, bodies aren't treated as obstacles.
32:36 --> 32:42 [SPEAKER_00]: and faith isn't about withdrawing from reality, but engaging it more fully.
32:45 --> 32:54 [SPEAKER_00]: And I think for many of us, especially those who have gone through some form of deconstruction, this shift can feel both disorienting and freeing.
32:56 --> 33:00 [SPEAKER_00]: Because it invites us to reconnect with parts of ourselves that may have been sidelined.
33:01 --> 33:13 [SPEAKER_00]: to take our lived experience seriously, to listen to our bodies, to care about what happens here and now, not just what we've been told happens later.
33:14 --> 33:24 [SPEAKER_00]: So maybe the question isn't just whether dualism is right or wrong, maybe the deeper question is, what kind of world does it create?
33:25 --> 33:29 [SPEAKER_00]: And what kind of world becomes possible when we begin to let it go?
33:31 --> 33:38 [SPEAKER_00]: So as we bring this conversation to a close, I think it's worth stepping back and asking a simple, but important question.
33:40 --> 33:51 [SPEAKER_00]: How much of what we believe, how much of how we see the world is something we've actually examined, and how much of it is something we've simply inherited.
33:53 --> 33:57 [SPEAKER_00]: Because for many of us, dualistic thinking wasn't something we consciously chose.
34:01 --> 34:07 [SPEAKER_00]: In the air we breathed, in the language we were given, and the way faith was framed.
34:08 --> 34:20 [SPEAKER_00]: A quiet assumption that the spiritual matters more than the physical, that the eternal matters more than the present, that what happens out there matters more than what happens here.
34:22 --> 34:25 [SPEAKER_00]: And over time, that framework starts to shape everything.
34:26 --> 34:39 [SPEAKER_00]: how we see ourselves, how we relate to our bodies, how we understand other people, how we make decisions, and as we've seen, how entire systems operate.
34:42 --> 34:45 [SPEAKER_00]: So the challenge isn't just to identify dualism as an idea.
34:47 --> 34:49 [SPEAKER_00]: It's to recognize where it may still be shaping us.
34:50 --> 35:10 [SPEAKER_00]: where it might be influencing how we think about our worth, our bodies, our relationships, our communities, where it might be showing up and the way we divide the world into categories that feel clear, but may not actually reflect the complexity of reality, or the heart of the Christian story.
35:12 --> 35:17 [SPEAKER_00]: Because if the biblical vision is more integrated than divided, more embodied
35:18 --> 35:25 [SPEAKER_00]: more about restoration than escape, then letting go of dualism isn't just a philosophical shift.
35:26 --> 35:29 [SPEAKER_00]: It's a reorientation, a different way of seeing.
35:31 --> 35:35 [SPEAKER_00]: It might mean questioning long-held assumptions about what matters most.
35:36 --> 35:42 [SPEAKER_00]: It might mean rethinking how we've been taught to separate the spiritual from the rest of our lives.
35:43 --> 35:53 [SPEAKER_00]: It might mean asking whether the systems we've participated in, or benefited from, have been shaped by categories that simplify reality at the expense of people.
35:54 --> 36:02 [SPEAKER_00]: And it might mean asking a deeper question, not just what is true, but what kind of world does this belief create?
36:04 --> 36:10 [SPEAKER_00]: Because ideas don't just stay in our heads, they shape our lives, they shape our communities, they shape our institutions.
36:11 --> 36:16 [SPEAKER_00]: And sometimes, they shape who gets protected and who gets left behind.
36:17 --> 36:20 [SPEAKER_00]: So maybe the invitation here is simple.
36:21 --> 36:22 [SPEAKER_00]: Pay attention.
36:24 --> 36:26 [SPEAKER_00]: Pay attention to the frameworks you've inherited.
36:27 --> 36:30 [SPEAKER_00]: Pay attention to the categories you've been given.
36:31 --> 36:33 [SPEAKER_00]: Pay attention to what's being elevated.
36:33 --> 36:46 [SPEAKER_00]: and what's being minimized, and ask yourself, is this helping me see the world more clearly, or is it dividing it in ways that were never meant to be there in the first place?
36:48 --> 36:55 [SPEAKER_00]: And maybe, just maybe, a more whole way of seeing leads to a more whole way of living.
36:57 --> 36:57 [SPEAKER_00]: Thanks for listening.